Armed forces: ethical decision making

Using this tool kit

Armed forces doctors can use this essential guidance on how best to fulfil their ethical obligations as medical doctors in the military context. The tool kit covers:

ArrowGuiding principles
ArrowIntroduction to tool kit
ArrowManaging dual loyalties
ArrowConsent and capacity
ArrowConfidentiality
ArrowCompetence
ArrowTreating detainees
ArrowIdentifying and reporting unethical practices and abuse

 

Guiding principles

The health of my patient will be my first consideration.  

World Medical Association, Declaration of Geneva

Doctors in the armed forces work in closed and hierarchical command structures. As members of the military, they are likely to identify closely with, and experience strong loyalty towards, the unit or service of which they are a part.
At the same time, doctors’ professional obligations require them to prioritise their ethical duties to their patients over and above their responsibilities and loyalties to the military.

These factors can result in conflicts of interest for military doctors. It is vital that doctors remain alert to the ways in which such conflicts can impact on their ability to meet their binding ethical obligations.

The following core principles form the basis of the guidance throughout this tool kit.

  • The actions of all military personnel, including medical personnel, should at all times be proportionate and just.
  • The conduct of military doctors should accord with the ethical standards of civilian practitioners.
  • Medical care should be delivered according to clinical need, impartially and without discrimination.
  • Doctors should not be involved in or cooperate with torture, or cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment or punishment, which is illegal in all circumstances.
  • Doctors should report violations of ethics and applicable laws, or practices that interfere with their ability to meet their ethical duties, to the appropriate chain of command.
  • Doctors must be able to justify any departure from accepted ethical principles or guidelines.

 

Armed forces ethics tool kit

Ethical decision-making for doctors in the armed forces: a tool kit

Download the full guidance

Ethical decision making for doctors in the armed forces tool kit (PDF)

Further information and support

More support and background reading on these issues is available.

Find out more

Request a hard copy

The tool kit is available in pocket sized, wire bound, tear resistant format.

To request a copy:

email the BMA